Robby Pardlo, Co‑Founder of City High and Voice Behind 'What Would You Do?,' Dies

Robby Pardlo — the New Jersey singer‑songwriter who co‑founded early‑2000s R&B trio City High — has died, friends confirmed Friday.

Public music bios list Pardlo’s birth year as 1977, which would make him 48 this year, though his family has not confirmed an exact date of birth.[1]

Terrill “Rellion” Paul, a longtime collaborator, announced the news in a Facebook post, calling Pardlo “one kind‑hearted person who would literally give the shirt off your back” and sharing recent photos of the two men alongside an early snapshot of the group. No cause of death has been released, and Pardlo’s family has yet to issue a formal statement.

Formed under Wyclef Jean’s Booga Basement imprint, City High — Pardlo, Claudette Ortiz and Ryan Toby — broke through in 2001 with “What Would You Do?,” an unflinching narrative about poverty and survival that reached No. 8 on the Billboard Hot 100 and earned a Grammy nomination for best R&B performance by a duo or group. The group’s gold‑certified, self‑titled debut also produced the Top 20 single “Caramel,” featuring Eve.

Behind the chart success, Pardlo wrestled with alcoholism. His struggle was chronicled in a 2010 episode of A&E’s “Intervention,” where he linked his addiction to the group’s abrupt breakup in 2003. Ortiz later alleged their teenage relationship had been abusive, telling Washington, D.C.’s Majic 102.3 in 2013 that she “had to choose safety over the group.” Pardlo did not publicly respond to those claims but credited the televised rehab program with a lengthy stretch of sobriety.

After City High dissolved, Pardlo largely retreated from the spotlight, surfacing for occasional writing sessions and small‑venue appearances. In his Facebook tribute, Paul said the two recently joked about “getting old together” and still “talking trash like Claud Banks and Ray Gibson,” the bickering cellmates from the 1999 film “Life.”

Funeral arrangements have not been announced. Paul ended his post with a promise to keep his friend’s legacy alive: “We were supposed to do life together… I will miss you so much.”

Sources
[1] Birth year appears as 1977 in AllMusic artist profile, Discogs database entry and A&M Records’ 2001 press kit; no family confirmation yet released.